Beef Jerky Hub
Because the Best Jerky Doesn’t Come from a Store
Dark homemade jerky strips arranged beside thyme

Old Fashioned Beef Jerky Recipe: A Timeless Taste

By Charles Joseph · Updated
Share
Share
Copy URL

This recipe will teach you how to make delicious old-fashioned beef jerky. Salty and sweet, smoky and tangy. Our famous beef jerky pays homage to the beginnings of this popular snack. A timeless piece to be enjoyed repeatedly!

Our protein-rich beef jerky, which is made with beef that has a rich flavor, demonstrates quality with each bite’s texture and moisture. It is a tasty and satiating snack for the car, the game, the work, or any other time.

Slicing Meat

The first step in creating this teriyaki beef jerky is choosing a lean beef cut. I picked the bottom round to make this tasty beef jerky. Please, check out the list of the ideal beef you can use while making beef jerky.

A hand holding a bottom round roast
Bottom round is the cut used here, giving the batch a lean base for the classic seasoning.

The cut should be completely free of visible fat before slicing it into strips for jerky. Because fat spoils more quickly than meat, the jerky that results will have a shorter shelf life.

A knife trimming the outside of a raw beef roast
Trim off any fat you can see before slicing the beef.

We need about 1 lb or 450 grams (15.9 oz.) of beef.

Raw beef on a scale reading 450 grams
Weigh the beef before the marinade bath, then save the number for the finish.

I hand-sliced the meat for this recipe; take care to use a very sharp knife. Before slicing, you may also partially freeze the beef. This helps to keep the meat rigid while slicing and facilitates cutting uniform portions.

To your preferred thickness, cut the beef strips. Depending on the recipe, I frequently slice the meat at a thickness of 14′, either with or against the grain.

A cook slicing beef into long strips
Even thickness helps the pieces dry at a similar pace despite differences in their length.
Sponsored

Making Marinade

This recipe is so delicious since it contains high-quality ingredients, such as the savory flavor of the soy sauce, the spiciness of the black pepper, and the sweetness of the brown sugar.

The special flavor is added thanks to Liquid smoke, Worcestershire source, and flavored powders.

Brown sugar, soy sauce, Worcestershire sauce, and seasonings
Familiar pantry favorites come together for that classic sweet-and-savory jerky flavor.

Properly combine all the ingredients first in a small bowl or zip-top bag. Add the strips to the marinade thoroughly to ensure that each one is uniformly coated. Marinating for 6–24 hours is more important in the refrigerator than on the kitchen counter.

Beef strips being stirred in a bowl of seasoned marinade
Keep the beef in the fridge and turn the strips now and then to coat both sides.

Therefore, don’t leave raw meat out on the table. Food safety is very important.

During marinating, take the bag out of the fridge and mix the strips several times to ensure they are evenly covered with the marinade.

Dehydrating the Jerky

The beef jerky will have a stronger taste the longer it is marinated. After the meat has finished marinating, any excess beef jerky marinade needs to be filtered in a strainer. We gave this 10 hours to sit.

After being strained in a strainer, the beef jerky strips should be spread out on paper towels to absorb any extra marinade.

Marinated beef slices draining separately on paper towels
Drain and blot the excess marinade before moving the slices to the dehydrator.

I use a Nesco dehydrator was preparing my beef jerky, but you could also make it in the oven or a smoker if you prefer.

Sale
Nesco FD-75A Snackmaster Pro Food Dehydrator
  • Dry your jerky evenly without the hassle of rotating trays.
  • Keep your oven free for dinner while your next batch of jerky dries.
  • Make a bigger jerky stash by expanding to twelve trays. Extra trays are sold separately.

Make sure there is space between each strip of beef jerky to facilitate even drying.

Marinated beef slices arranged around a dehydrator tray
The open gaps around the slices are part of the drying setup, not wasted tray space.

Dehydrate the beef for three hours at the dehydrator’s highest setting, which is either 160F or 165F. After that, you can finish it by lowering the temperature to 145F.

Darkened old-fashioned jerky pieces on a round tray
Compare a cooled piece's texture with the rest of the batch before deciding whether more drying is needed.

You should start checking the jerky to see if it has finished drying around the third or fourth-hour mark. After being removed from the oven, dehydrator, or smoker, a piece of beef jerky needs to cool for five minutes to reach room temperature.

When you divide the beef jerky in half, it should bend and fracture but not completely break apart. The meat also exhibits white filaments. The fibers are most obvious when a piece is torn or twisted in half.

You’ll end up with around ⅓ of your starting weight in jerky. Our original pound of beef was 15.9 oz. and after the cooking we got 6.6 oz. (186 grams).

Finished jerky on a scale reading 186 grams
186 grams at the finish. A homemade batch with an old-fashioned snack-shop feel.

Recipe of Sweet and Spicy Beef Jerky

Makes 5 servings Preparation Time: 30 minutes Marinade Time: 6-24 hours, average 8 hours Drying Time: 4-8 hours, average 6 hours

IngredientsCost
1 lb beef — Bottom Round beef (any could work)$7.99 per 1 lb. at Weis
1/2 cup soy sauce$1.52 for a 15 oz. container at Walmart (1/2 cup or 4 oz. = 0.40 cents)
2 tablespoons brown sugar$2.17 for 2lb. a container at Walmart (31 tbsp. per pound means that 2 tbsp. equates to 0.07 cents)
2 teaspoons of black pepper ground$3.98 for a 3.12 oz. container at Walmart (6 tsp. per oz. means that 2 teaspoons equates to 0.42 cents)
1 teaspoon of garlic powderBetween $4 and $5 for a 2.33 oz. container (6 tsp. per oz. means that 1 teaspoon equates to 0.28 cents)
1/2 cup of Worcestershire$1.00 for a 10 oz. container at Wallmart (1/2 cup or 4 oz. = 0.40 cents)
1 teaspoon of onion powderBetween $4 and $5 for a 1.73 oz. container (6 tsp. per oz. means that 1 teaspoon equates to 0.38 cents)
1 teaspoon Liquid smoke$1.34 for a 4 oz. container at Walmart (6 tsp. per one oz. means that 1 tablespoon equates to 0.06 cents)
1 teaspoon of saltabout 0.01 cents
Total Cost:$9.61/6.6 oz. (full cost: meat + ingredients)
Sponsored

Step-By-Step Instructions

Dark homemade jerky strips arranged beside thyme

Old Fashioned Beef Jerky Recipe

This recipe will teach you how to make delicious old-fashioned beef jerky. Salty and sweet, smoky and tangy. Our famous beef jerky pays homage to the beginnings of this popular snack. A timeless piece to be enjoyed repeatedly!

Prep Time
30 minutes
Cook Time
5 hours
Marinade Time
10 hours
Course: SnackCuisine: AmericanKeyword: Beef JerkyServings: 5Calories: 225kcalCost: $9.61

Equipment


Ingredients


Instructions

  1. The beef should be trimmed of all visible fat, wrapped in plastic wrap, and partially frozen in the freezer for a few hours
  2. Slice the beef into 14" strips against the grain for easier chewing after removing it from the freezer. For chewier jerky, cut with the grain
  3. Sliced beef should be added to the mixture and marinated for 8 to 24 hours in the fridge
  4. Remove the meat from the refrigerator after it has completed marinating, then strain the extra marinade. Paper towels are used to pat the strips dry
  5. Dehydrate the beef for three hours at the dehydrator's highest setting, which is either 160F or 165F. After that, you can finish it by lowering the temperature to 145F
  6. When the jerky bends and cracks but does not split in half, it is ready

Nutrition

Serving: 37.2g | Calories: 225kcal | Carbohydrates: 11.6g | Protein: 29.4g | Fat: 5.7g | Saturated Fat: 2.1g | Cholesterol: 81mg | Sodium: 1223mg | Potassium: 447mg | Fiber: 0.5g | Sugar: 5.7g | Calcium: 15mg | Iron: 18mg

QUOTE:

"You might be a redneck if you think that beef jerky and moon pies are two of the major food groups."

-- Jeff Foxworthy

About the Author

In 2017, a good friend introduced me to the most amazing beef jerky I had ever tasted. And his source was from the most unexpected of places--a random guy in Thailand whom he had met while living there. Although I had been eating jerky since as far back as I could remember, I was genuinely blown away by the flavor. I realized the best beef jerky doesn't come from a store. This experience inspired me to create Beef Jerky Hub and put into writing all the things I've since learned about this amazing food. If you're interested, you can read more about my story here.