Beef Jerky Hub
Because the Best Jerky Doesn’t Come from a Store
Brown sugar beef jerky strips beside a halved orange

Brown Sugar Beef Jerky: Satisfy Your Cravings with This Recipe

By Charles Joseph · Updated
Share
Share
Copy URL

Seeking a scrumptious and simple beef jerky recipe? Look no further! This delightful recipe features brown sugar for a touch of sweetness, coupled with a smoky essence that elevates its taste. It’s an ideal snack to keep on hand for those unexpected hunger pangs.

Not only will this recipe appease your appetite, but it’s also a breeze to prepare.

Beef Jerky with Brown Sugar Ingredients

Brown sugar, sauces, mustard, and spices for the jerky marinade
Mix the sugar thoroughly into the liquids so the sweetness is distributed throughout the batch.
Sponsored

Selecting the Beef

If you’re searching for the ideal meat to make beef jerky, consider using eye-of-round beef. With its minimal fat content, eye-of-round allows you to create a beef jerky that is both high in protein and low in calories. Additionally, it offers a leaner alternative compared to cuts like sirloin or chuck roast.

I bought my eye-of-round beef at Walmart for $6.61/lb.

Packaged eye of round steaks on a kitchen counter
Lean eye of round leaves less surface fat to remove before you start slicing.

Preparing the Beef to Make Jerky

Some types of beef are often considered fatty food. However, removing the fat from the meat leaves you with a lean and healthy protein.

A cook trimming fat from raw beef with a knife
Weigh the beef after trimming to match the marinade to the meat you will actually use.

Weighing the meat is an important step if you want to make sure that you have enough meat for the recipe and also how much beef jerky we’ll get after dehydration.

Raw beef on a digital scale reading 460 grams
A quick weigh-in now makes the finished batch's shrinking act easier to follow.

Freezing the Beef

Here is a tip for making jerky: freeze the beef before you slice it (from 1 to 2 hours). The beef will be firmer and easier to cut if it has been in the freezer for a little while. Make sure you take the meat out of the freezer when the ice starts to form on its surface. If you leave it in longer, it will be too hard and difficult to cut.

Firm beef being sliced into narrow strips
Chill the meat until firm enough to slice evenly without having to force the knife.
Sponsored

Slicing the Beef

When ready, cut the beef into strips not wider than ¼ inch. The thinner the strips, the less time it will take for your jerky to get dry.

Suppose you want a more pleasant texture, cut across or against the grain. Cutting with the grain will make jerky harder to chew and tougher.

Marinating the Beef

The next step is to gather all the ingredients and make a marinade. You’ll need to mix the ingredients we listed above in the proper proportions. I use a measuring cup for the perfect proportions.

Dark marinade in a clear measuring cup
Find a sweet-and-savory balance you love, then keep those measurements for next time.

Now put your beef in the marinade. It should sit for 6 to 24 hours (in a refrigerator). The longer you let it sit, the stronger the flavor would be.

Beef strips submerged in brown sugar marinade in a bowl
Turn the slices to coat them evenly, then cover and refrigerate during marinating.

Drying the Beef

You can take the excess marinade off beef by putting them on paper towels. This will make the drying process faster.

Marinated beef strips draining on paper towels
Blot excess liquid gently so you remove drips without wiping away all the seasoning.

There are three ways to dry beef jerky. One way is to use an oven, another way is with an electric smoker, and the last way is with a food dehydrator. We used a food dehydrator because it is small and easy to use.

To do the job, you just have to lay meat strips on the trays of the dehydrator and let it work for 5 – 8 hours at 160 degrees F.

Ours took 7 hours in the dehydrator (I bought mine on Amazon), but yours might take less time if the meat is thinner or more time if the meat is thicker.

Sale
Nesco FD-75A Snackmaster Pro Food Dehydrator
  • Dry your jerky evenly without the hassle of rotating trays.
  • Keep your oven free for dinner while your next batch of jerky dries.
  • Make a bigger jerky stash by expanding to twelve trays. Extra trays are sold separately.
Seasoned beef strips spaced around a round dehydrator tray
Keep the pieces in one layer so the sweet marinade does not glue overlapping slices together.

You will end up with ⅓ of your weight as jerky. Look at the scale below: we started with 1 pound of beef and ended up with 6.63 oz of beef jerky.

Finished beef jerky on a scale reading 188 grams
460 grams in, 188 grams out. A smaller pile with plenty of brown-sugar appeal.
Sponsored

Recipe

This recipe serves 5 people.

  • preparation time: 30 minutes
  • marinade time: 8 hours
  • drying time: 7 hours
IngredientsCost
1 lb. of beef; I choose Eye of round, but any could work$6.61 per 1 lb. at Walmart
1 teaspoon of dijon mustard$3 – 4 dollar range for an 8 oz. container ( 6 tsp. per one oz. means that 1 teaspoon equates to 0.06 cents )
1/4 cup soy sauce$1.52 for a 5 oz. container at Walmart (1/4 cup or 2 oz. = 0.61 cents)
1/4 cup waterI used tap water so it was essentially free
1 teaspoon salt1 cent for 1 teaspoon of salt
1/2 cup dark brown sugar$2.17 for 2lb. a container at Walmart (1/2 cup or 4 oz. = 0.27 cents)
2 teaspoon black pepper$3.98 for 3.12 oz. a container at Walmart (6 tsp. per oz. means that 1 teaspoon equates to 0.21 cents or 0.42 cents per 2 teaspoons)
2 teaspoon onion powderBetween $4 and $5 for a 1.73 oz. container (6 tsp. per oz. means that 1 teaspoon equates to 0.38 cents or 0.76 cents per 2 teaspoons)
2 teaspoon garlic powderBetween $4 and $5 for a 2.33 oz. container (6 tsp. per oz. means that 1 teaspoon equates to 0.28 cents or 0.56 cents per 2 teaspoons )
1/4 cup soy sauce$1.52 for a 5 oz. container at Walmart (1/4 cup or 2 oz. = 0.61 cents)
1/4 cup Worcestershire sauce$1.00 for a 10 oz. container at Walmart (1/4 cup or 2 oz. = 0.20 cents)
1/4 teaspoon cayenne pepper$3.97 per a 1.7 oz. container at Walmart (6 tsp. per oz. means that 1/4 tsp equates to 0.10 cents )
Total Cost:$9.6/6.63 oz. (full cost: meat + ingredients)

Shot Instruction

  1. The first step is to trim the fat from your beef. 
  2. Next, cut it into slices that are no more than ¼ inch thick and then slice against or across the grain. 
  3. Mix all of the marinade ingredients. 
  4. Then put beef and marinade in a container or Ziploc bag and place it in the fridge for 6-24 hours. 
  5. Remove excess liquid from the beef with a paper towel. 
  6. Dry your beef in a food dehydrator, oven, or electric smoker at 160 degrees F for 5 – 8 hours; when the beef bend and crack without snapping, it’s ready!
Brown sugar beef jerky strips beside a halved orange

Beef Jerky Recipe with Brown Sugar

Are you hunting for a tasty and simple recipe for beef jerky? This is the ideal one! Brown sugar is used in its preparation, giving it a pleasant sweetness and smoky flavor that give it an outstanding flavor. You should always keep some on hand in case you are hungry. Don't forget to try the protein-rich beef jerky with brown sugar, which will sate your appetite!

Prep Time
30 minutes
Cook Time
8 hours
Marinade Time
7 hours
Course: SnackCuisine: AmericanKeyword: Beef JerkyServings: 5Calories: 251kcalCost: $9.60

Equipment


Ingredients


Instructions

  1. The first step is to trim the fat from your beef.
  2. Next, cut it into slices that are no more than ¼ inch thick and then slice against or across the grain.
  3. Mix all of the marinade ingredients together.
  4. Then put beef and marinade in a container or Ziploc bag and place it in the fridge for 6-24 hours.
  5. Remove excess liquid from the beef with a paper towel.
  6. Dry your beef in a food dehydrator, oven, or electric smoker at 160 degrees F for 5 – 8 hours; when the beef bend and crack without snapping, it’s ready!

Nutrition

Serving: 37.6g | Calories: 251kcal | Carbohydrates: 19.4g | Protein: 28.7g | Fat: 5.8g | Saturated Fat: 2.1g | Cholesterol: 81mg | Sodium: 1392mg | Potassium: 440mg | Fiber: 0.4g | Sugar: 17.3g | Calcium: 22mg | Iron: 18mg

QUOTE:

"You might be a redneck if you think that beef jerky and moon pies are two of the major food groups."

-- Jeff Foxworthy

About the Author

In 2017, a good friend introduced me to the most amazing beef jerky I had ever tasted. And his source was from the most unexpected of places--a random guy in Thailand whom he had met while living there. Although I had been eating jerky since as far back as I could remember, I was genuinely blown away by the flavor. I realized the best beef jerky doesn't come from a store. This experience inspired me to create Beef Jerky Hub and put into writing all the things I've since learned about this amazing food. If you're interested, you can read more about my story here.